Debate Erupts Over Classification of Crimson Desert as an RPG Ahead of Release

The anticipation for Crimson Desert is palpable, but with it comes a pressing question: Is it an RPG? And does that distinction really hold significance? As the game, described as an "open-world action-adventure," nears its launch, opinions are diverse. Developer Pearl Abyss offers the following insight into the game: Crimson Desert is set in the stunning yet harsh continent of Pywel, where players will journey as the character Kliff Greymane, aiming to reclaim lost treasures. Players will navigate uncharted territories, confront various adversaries, and uncover the marvels that the world presents. Notably, Pearl Abyss refrains from labeling Crimson Desert as an RPG, nor does it categorize it as a 'soulslike' game. Instead, it sticks to the straightforward classification of an "open-world action-adventure" title. So, why is there a debate about its RPG status? The discussion ignited on social media, particularly by a user known as Synth Potato, who pointed out the game's progression system, asserting that the absence of levels and experience points—common features in role-playing games—means it shouldn't be classified as an RPG. In Crimson Desert, players acquire new abilities by discovering artifacts and enhancing gear through crafting or purchases, suggesting it belongs more to the action-adventure genre. However, does this exclude Crimson Desert from being considered an RPG? Some argue that the ability to control a character within an open world and progress in any form qualifies it as a role-playing game. Yet, this raises further questions: Would that imply every open-world title is an RPG? What about games like Grand Theft Auto or Red Dead Redemption 2? Even The Legend of Zelda, which lacks traditional leveling, is often included in RPG discussions. It's important to note that, similar to The Legend of Zelda, players in Crimson Desert assume the role of a defined protagonist (Kliff) and follow a predetermined narrative. There aren’t significant choices that alter the storyline or lead to various endings; rather, the game offers freedom in exploration within a more structured experience. One fan pointed out, "It’s clear it’s not marketed as an RPG, yet it has numerous RPG mechanics, such as gear scores and skill progression." Another added, "The definition of RPG has become increasingly ambiguous, especially with the influx of action-adventure games incorporating RPG elements." A third fan remarked that their expectations align more with games like Just Cause or Shadow of Mordor, which is precisely what they were hoping for. This caution in labeling is likely a strategic move by the developers, as the term 'RPG' carries specific expectations that Crimson Desert may not fully meet. Ms5000Watts on social media reflected this sentiment, stating that the game is designed as an open-world action adventure with an enjoyable combat system. Will Powers, the marketing director at Pearl Abyss America, recently urged players not to anticipate traditional RPG elements, particularly concerning character choices and their consequences. Instead, he emphasized that the vast array of activities within the game will allow players to shape their unique experiences through personal interpretations. "You select your character's progression, and through your imagination, you’ll create a distinct journey compared to others, even while following the same overarching narrative," Powers clarified. In light of the ongoing debate, Powers articulated why Pearl Abyss opts against categorizing Crimson Desert as an RPG, despite welcoming fans who might choose to label it as such. He acknowledged the game's adventurous nature and diverse gameplay, stating, "It's not my role to dictate how others experience it. If players feel the game’s RPG elements warrant that classification, then so be it. I’m simply explaining our perspective on the matter." Crimson Desert is set to launch on March 19, retailing at $69.99. Pearl Abyss has also confirmed that the game will not feature any cosmetic cash shop or microtransactions.